Dorothee
Germany
|
Last year some video material appeared on the Internet showing sheep getting mistreated and injured during their shearing for wool. Many animal rights activists and animal welfare activists took this as a sign to encourage people not to buy any more products based on sheep-wool and instead focus on animal-friendly cotton. While I may approve of people fighting for animal-welfare, I still think that human beings – especially children and people from the least developing countries – deserve more protection than them. Fact is however that according to a brochure produced by the “United States Department of Labor” – the one my boyfriend Jörn gave me as a Christmas-gift – that in Argentina, Azerbaijan, Benin, China, India, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Mali, Paraguay, Tajikistan, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Zambia and Uzbekistan – three of which being least developing countries – owners of cotton-plantations commonly use children as low-paid and awfully-treated workers. These children have to grow the plants, do the harvest, can’t go to school during that time and often their wages are just good enough in order for the family not to starve to death. While it may be an easy task to control whether or not a farmer living in an industrial nation treats his sheep properly, it may be a lot harder to check whether or not the owner of a cotton-plant in a least developed country – where these plantations are often hard to reach due to their location and where bribery and other even worse crimes happen more often than here – treats his workers properly and never uses children for this hard work. In fact that’s the only reason why I though still thinking that animal-welfare is important disapprove of people encouraging others to buy cotton-products instead of sheep-wool-products, because to me the fight against child-labor matters more than the fight against animal-cruelty committed by just a handful of shepherds. Another last pro-sheep-wool argument and contra-cotton-argument of mine is that both sheep-wool-based and cotton-based products are made of not just one raw material, but many…and often aren’t even produced in the same country the raw-material comes from, making the label that says which country this cloth or whatever comes from rather useless. You can’t just say things like “Oh! The label says that this cotton-wool-based shirt was made in Great Britain and not in Argentina, Azerbaijan, Benin, China, India, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Mali, Paraguay, Tajikistan, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Zambia or Uzbekistan. Thus I can buy it without having to worry about child-labor!”
|