Learn English with English, baby!

Join for FREE!

Social_nav_masthead_logged_in

English Forums

Use our English forums to learn English. The message boards are great for English questions and English answers. The more you contribute, the more all members can practice English!

:  

English Talk

HELP!

feresyosira

Turkey

The man was killed BY or WITH a knife? Which one is correct gramatically?

10:27 AM Jun 07 2008 |

The iTEP® test

  • Schedule an iTEP® test and take the official English Practice Test.

    Take Now >

aljensen

aljensen

United States

killed by a person (alive)

killed with an instrument  (inanimate)

04:49 AM Jun 08 2008 |

dadong

dadong

China

good

08:24 AM Jun 08 2008 |

Randyinseattle

United States

Although a bus is not inanimate, I think most Americans would say killed by a bus, hit by a bus. Perhaps it is the ability for a bus to move.

06:28 AM Jun 11 2008 |

aljensen

aljensen

United States

yeah that's true – killed by a bus, killed by a car

 run over by a bus, run over by a car 

Also, you can say "Death by poison, Death by stabbing, etc."

 

06:41 AM Jun 11 2008 |

jenvik

United States

A good way to test phrases like this is to go to Google, change the language to English (in the Advanced Search, there is a language choice option), and enter the phrase in quotes (very important!).

"killed by a knife" – 663 hits

"killed with a knife" – 16,900 hits

Therefore, "killed with a knife" wins the Googlefight! 

04:32 AM Jun 12 2008 |

tiffintime

tiffintime

Sri Lanka

I also often use Google to test English phrases or collocation samples I am not too sure about.

 

06:08 AM Jun 12 2008 |

latin-lover

Italy

by for people and with for instruments….right.

About animals?

I've read in somewhere " a man was bited by a dog".

Is it right?

08:29 AM Jun 12 2008 |

tiffintime

tiffintime

Sri Lanka

" a man was bitten by a dog".

yeah – "by a dog" is correct.

Well, it's valid for humans also – A part of his ear was bitten off by a boxer.

10:07 AM Jun 12 2008 |

jolka

jolka

Poland

for me the biggest problem is with prepositions. I'm studying English for many years and I still have problems with deciding when to use "the", "a/an" or no preposition at all.

Is there any key to solve my problem, or I shold practice more?

02:01 PM Jun 12 2008 |

Randyinseattle

United States

An apple. A pig.

If the next word starts with a vowel, you use "an. If the next word starts with a consonant, then you use "a". 

02:38 PM Jun 12 2008 |